“The difference between a million views and 28 million views is how you package it.”
Episode Overview
7 Creator Lessons From Paddy Galloway
Lesson 1: YouTube is a click & watch platform
YouTube isn’t just about making great videos - it’s about winning the click. Paddy explained that small creators often spend 95% of their time on filming and editing, but the real leverage comes from packaging. He pointed to astrophotographer Ian Lauer, who went from 2-3K views per video to over 1M by focusing more on titles and thumbnails rather than just production.
Lesson 2: Spend more time on ideation & packaging
Top creators dedicate 30% of their time to ideation and packaging, compared to the 5% most small creators spend. Paddy shared how Ian’s shift in focus - from “I photographed the Milky Way” to “Photographing the Milky Way in 10 minutes, 1 hour, and 24 hours” - unlocked massive growth because it created a clear curiosity gap and visual story.
Lesson 3: Be familiar, but unexpected
A video should feel recognizable in its niche while adding a twist that makes people pause. Johnny Harris’s “$25K vs $25M” video does this, which followed a well-known three-tier comparison format but applied it to income levels. Similarly, Paddy suggested even niche creators (like in golf or space) can borrow comparison frameworks from outside niches to stand out.
Lesson 4: Tiny tweaks create massive results
Sometimes growth isn’t about overhauling everything - it’s about small optimizations. Paddy mentioned Tim Gabe, who improved a thumbnail on an old video by about 30-40% and saw the video snowball into 40x more views per day. These tweaks compound because YouTube rewards videos that capture clicks and sustain watch time.
Lesson 5: Steal formats across niches
Great formats don’t need to be invented — they can be adapted. Paddy mentioned Red Bull’s “World’s Fastest Drone vs F1 Car” video, which drew inspiration from car drag race channels like Carwow. Similarly, formats like “$1 vs $100” or “10 minutes vs 24 hours” can be transplanted into new niches to feel fresh to audiences that haven’t seen them before
Lesson 6: Ride it until they stop you
When a format works, double down - don’t abandon it just because others start copying. Paddy explained that many creators get spooked when copycats flood their niche, but in reality, if the format still works for your audience, you shouldn’t walk away. He compared it to American football’s “run it until they stop you”: milk the format while it delivers results.
Lesson 7: Creators = artists + distributors
The best creators balance artistry with distribution. Casey Neistat may sit more on the artist side, while MrBeast is firmly a distributor. Creators who want to last need to find their place on that spectrum - blending creativity with repeatability, audience empathy, and strategy. Being sustainable as a creator means respecting both sides.
Shownotes
Paddy Introduction
Colin & Samir introduce YouTube strategist Paddy Galloway, credited with billions of views.
The View Maximizer
Paddy describes himself as a 'view maximizer' and shares his YouTube journey since 2006.
YouTube Today
Discussion on how YouTube has evolved into the world’s biggest streaming platform, dominating TV, radio, and podcasts.
Breaking Through Competition
What it takes to stand out in the most competitive era of YouTube while still leveraging algorithm opportunities.
Click & Watch Platform
Why YouTube is about clicks and decisions, not just videos — creators must win the click with ideas and packaging.
Case Study: Ian Lauer Astro
Astrophotography channel jumps from 2K to 1M views by reframing video packaging and comparison formats.
Tiny Tweaks, Massive Results
A thumbnail adjustment boosted Tim Gabe's video to 40x more views per day, showing the exponential impact of small changes.
The 3 Rules of YouTube
Colin & Samir share their rules for YouTube: 1. If they don't click they don't watch, 2. Respect their time, 3. Do you want more stuff like this?
Familiar but Unexpected
Successful packaging borrows recognizable elements while adding unexpected twists, with examples from Johnny Harris.
Borrowing Formats Across Niches
Paddy explains how creators can adapt proven formats from unrelated niches, like $1 vs $100 comparisons.
Case Study: Andrew Millison
Permaculture creator’s Sahara Desert video gains 15M+ views by broadening packaging beyond the core niche.
Case Study: Red Bull
Inside Red Bull’s viral 'World’s Fastest Drone vs F1 Car' video and how it drew inspiration from Carwow’s drag races.
Packaging & Exaggeration
Exploring exaggeration versus clarity in titles and thumbnails, with examples like Veritasium’s 'Why Are 96,000,000 Black Balls on This Reservoir?'
Curiosity Gap Frameworks
Why superlatives, versus matchups, and three-step comparisons consistently perform on YouTube.
Exclusive Access Advantage
How creators like Jesser and Forrest Galante use access to unique experiences as a competitive edge.
The Power of Lists
Lists work if they’re specific and unique — Ali Abdaal calls himself a 'forward-thinking list man'.
Thumbnail Branding & Copycats
Advice for evolving thumbnails when competitors copy your style, without abandoning what works.
Artists vs Distributors
Balancing creativity with distribution — comparing Casey Neistat’s artistry and MrBeast’s data-driven strategy.
The 80% Rule
Creators should aim for 80% audience overlap in most videos, while reserving 20% for experimentation.
Experimentation & Expectations
Creators often panic over 8/10 videos, but Paddy suggests predicting expected performance before upload.
Beyond Metrics
Why brand perception, comments, and anecdotal feedback matter as much as CTR and retention.
.png)
.avif)
.avif)
